Monday, November 16, 2009

Review: Still Alice by Lisa Genova


One of my book groups chose this for this month's book. When I heard what we would be reading, I wrinkled my nose and sighed. This was a book I intended to give a miss as it just didn't much interest me and had such potential for the treacle that was evident in Nicholas Sparks' The Notebook (a book I loathed). I can't begin to explain how glad I am that I was forced to read this. The group's discussion was more personal than focused on the book but the book is really well done and viscerally effecting.

Alice is a Harvard professor whose specialty is cognitive psychology, specifically in the way that we make langauge. She is well respected in her field and frequently off giving speeches at conferences. Her husband is also a Harvard professor and their children are grown and pursuing their own lives. So when Alice starts to forget small things, she chalks it up to stress, tiredness, or perhaps even menopause, knowing that her symptoms are indeed normal for any of these situations. But when she goes out for a run and gets lost in harvard Square, a place she has been in countless times on countless days, she knows that she should see a doctor, still hoping that she'll be told that everything is normal and knowing that it isn't.

As Alice starts down the path of a probably diagnosis of Early Onset Alzheimer's disease, followed by genetic confirmation, Genova continues to have Alice herself narrate the story so the reader lives the denial, poignancy, and helplessness of the patient rather than the caregiver. And this decision adds to the power of the novel. Alice is a very intelligent woman. She knows exactly what she's losing, and it's more than her memories. It's the sense of herself and those things that make her uniquely Alice. In the early stages of the disease, she tells of her relationship with her grown children, and especially her youngest daughter, the family rebel. There is no suggestion that Alice has been the perfect mother, she details her failings honestly and believably, but it is the imperfect mother that they had whom each of her children wants to hold onto.

This is not a handbook on how to handle a loved one's descent into the fog of Alzheimer's. It is a powerful and heartbreaking look at the breakdown of the person, the family, and the relationships with outsiders that Alzheimer's strips from its victims. Alice's intention to leave this world before she can't answer her touchstone questions, the questions which define her sense of self is shattering, understandable, and begs the question of who a person is if those things that defined them, internally and externally are all gone.

Genova's novel is really exquisitely done. The characters are human, with the failings and frustrations of real people. And Alice is, of course, the central character, showing the reader, through the eyes of the afflicted, the great extent of this horrible disease. Each of the women in my book group who had had a family member affected by this disease, early onset or not was grateful for the insight into the mind of the sufferer, even when that insight was necessarily painful. And all of us admitted to sobbing in the end. This disease ravages so many, those with the diease and those caring for someone with the disease. It truly is a thief and Genova has shone a light on the great need for better understanding, more research, and ultimately a cure. Highly recommended.

12 comments:

  1. I read this book last year, I think, and it still has stayed with me. It's very hard to understand this terrible disease and how it affects everyone. Reading about it from the patient's viewpoint was difficult but necessary to realize just what this disease takes from a person.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This seems like a very powerful and touching book. The perspective is also unique; I think that writing from a patient's point of view gives us a gritty look into the impact of the disease.

    ReplyDelete
  3. My wonderful grandmother had Alzheimer's & died by inches over about 10 years. I still miss her so very much. This sounds good, but I don't think I'll put myself through it. Thanks for the review.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I have always wanted to read this book, but haven't got around to it yet.

    ReplyDelete
  5. My book club read this book too and we had mixed emotions. Most of us really liked the book because it made us realize just how devastating this illness can be, but another member who has had a relative die from Alzheimer's felt that the author was not in a position to write about it from the first person point of view when she had never actually experienced the illness herself. Interesting how a book about an illness that touches us personally can have the opposite effect.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I CANNOT believe that you have read Nicholas Sparks!

    ReplyDelete
  7. I read this last month, and as the daughter of someone who had early-onset Alzheimer's, I found it particularly affecting, informative, and very well done. I think it's an important book that I'll be recommending time and again. Great review, and I'm glad you were so favorably impressed with it too!

    ReplyDelete
  8. I am so glad you liked this one, Kristen, despite your reservations. I put off reading it because of my personal connection to the novel--and now I want to share it with everyone. :-) It really is a worthwhile book to read. Thank you for your wonderful review.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Hi Kristen,

    Thanks so much for reading Still Alice with your book club and for taking the time to write such a great review of it here! So glad you enjoyed it, despite your reservations.

    Thanks again,
    Best wishes,
    Lisa

    ReplyDelete
  10. I have never gotten around to this one. I've heard wonderful things about it, but I admit the subject matter makes it a tough call for me.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Excellent review! So glad you liked it. I've found some great books the same way. A book club choice that I may not have picked myself turns out to be a wonderful read. I'll be adding this one to my list now! :)

    ReplyDelete
  12. I'm glad you gave it a chance - I think it's a very powerful story, written in a very unique way.

    ReplyDelete

I have had to disable the anonymous comment option to cut down on the spam and I apologize to those of you for whom this makes commenting a chore. I hope you'll still opt to leave me your thoughts. I love to hear what you think, especially so I know I'm not just whistling into the wind here at my computer.

Popular Posts