Sunday, October 26, 2014

Review: Cinnamon and Gunpowder by Eli Brown

There's just something about pirates, you know? Not the pirates from today, but the ones from the 18th and 19th centuries. In reality they were probably just as bloodthirsty, ruthless, and terrible in their time as today's pirates are in ours but looking back at them there's something inescapably appealing and even romantic about them. Take the outlaw life, put it on a ship, and float it in an ocean (or the Great Lakes, I'm not picky) and I will have a hard time keeping my hands off the book. Add in a talented chef and a commanding, intimidating female pirate captain and you have a kooky premise that just begs to be read. This was indeed the case with Eli Brown's swashbuckling, highly entertaining, and surprisingly concerned with social justice adventure novel, Cinnamon and Gunpowder.

Owen Wedgwood is a talented chef for Lord Ramsey, one of the major shareholders in the successful Pendleton Trading Company. Wedgwood is kidnapped when a dinner party to which Ramsey had been invited and to which he took Wedgwood in the capacity of chef de cuisine, is interrupted by the appearance of Mad Hannah Mabbot, a feared and fearsome pirate captain. Mabbot dispatches Ramsey to the devil and after tasting the meal, decides to make off with the cook for her own benefit. Wedgwood is horrified by his fate as a prisoner on the pirate ship as it heads off into the deep blue sea; he thinks of his late wife and his late employer, and tries to come up with a plan to escape these murderous rogues. When he is summoned to Mad Hannah's presence, he finds out the terms of his survival. Just as Westley in The Princess Bride is told that the Dread Pirate Roberts will "most likely kill you in the morning," our pudgy, prudish, and rather bumbling chef is told that he must create a unique and exquisite meal, concocted almost entirely from the meager stores aboard ship, for the captain once a week or he will suffer her wrath and face a long swim home, either whole or in pieces depending on the depth of her disappointment. Aside from having no choice whatsoever, Owen has his professional pride at stake and he agrees to the devil's bargain.

Wedge, as he comes to be called, tells of his incarceration on the ship, his attempts to coax something edible from the hard tack and weevil-ridden flour stores, his culinary creativity, and his dawning realization that there is more to the flame haired captain and her zeal in hunting down and destroying the Pendleton ships than he ever imagined in the splotched and hidden journal in which he confides most nights. As time passes, his first impressions of the crew and her captain are softened and humanized and he finds his own feelings about the raids on the Pendleton ships doing a volte face once he understands the reasons better. There is a fair bit of rollicking fun to be had in the adventures of the Flying Rose and her crew. There's also murder and plotting, high seas treachery, a saboteur, eccentric crew members, chasing after an elusive pirate called the Brass Fox, a jail break, trying to elude the notice of Laroche and his diabolically clever inventions, and over the top entertaining romps through the oceans of the world. In short, this is a perfect pirate tale.

But it is the something more than a pirate tale here that really elevates the novel. Brown touches on the history of the British tea trade and the effects that the forced introduction of opium has on the Chinese. There are the politics of social justice and the importance of family loyalty included as well. The characters are wonderfully fleshed out and quirky. With a passionate, determined, and charismatic female captain and a perpetually disapproving, tight-laced, often incompetent male chef, Brown has inverted the expected roles for men and women with the former in the role of nurturer and the latter in the role of adventurer. The slow revelation of Mabbot's motivations, her true character, and her deep-seated integrity don't mitigate her unforgiving vigilante justice or compensate for the gritty and terrible bloodbaths but they do add a dimension not often seen with respect to pirates or ascribed to women, especially those in 1819. Brown describes the meals that Wedge creates for the lady pirate as both exotic and in lushly sexual terms. And even though there is a slow developing romance involved, the larger part of the novel is over the top and humorous even as it touches on politics and morality. These are pirates (and a chef) like you've never seen before and the novel is a fun and fabulous read.


  1. I would never have picked this book up on my own, but after reading your review I'm adding it to my list. Thanks for getting me out of my genre box!

  2. Oh, I loved this book! I'm a sucker for pirate books as well. Great review!

  3. Hi Kristen,

    Having checked out this author, your review becomes even more observational and relevant in summing up the slightly quirky, off-the-wall nature of his writing style and storylines.

    Whilst I am not sure that this is a book I would be comfortable reading, Eli Brown books have met with some excellent ratings and reviews, and I do prefer the cover art you feature, over and above that of the alternative editions shown on Goodreads.

    Nice post and review, thanks for sharing.


  4. I love movies with pirates, but I don't remember reading any book with them. The story definitely sounds interesting and fun. I love how the captain pirate is actually a female. Thanks for sharing, I'll check it out :)

  5. What an unusual premise for a book! Not your usual pirate tale, and not something I had considered before. Thanks for an informative and honest take on it.

  6. I am doing a CHAIR DANCE RIGHT NOW because someone else loved it. I LOVE IT and I've seen it reviewed so little. Swoon!


I have had to disable the anonymous comment option to cut down on the spam and I apologize to those of you for whom this makes commenting a chore. I hope you'll still opt to leave me your thoughts. I love to hear what you think, especially so I know I'm not just whistling into the wind here at my computer.

Popular Posts