Tuesday, November 30, 2010

Review: The Lotus Eaters by Tatjana Soli

I have long had a fascination for Vietnam. I took a history class on the modern wars in high school and snuck my sophomore self into a junior/senior Vietnam War seminar class in college (in which I want it noted that I got a higher grade than my husband did when he took it several years later). I don't know if the fascination stems from knowing that my father got a deferment thanks to a shoulder injury from football thereby making my existence possible or from hearing my parents talk about friends they knew who were lost, either in the war or later, never having recovered from their experience in country. Clearly it was the defining event of their generation and it remains of great and abiding interest to me and mine.

American photo-journalist Helen Adams has been in Vietnam for 10 years. It is the place that claimed her brother's life, a place of great tragedy and of great and abiding love. She came to Vietnam on her own as a freelancer who dropped out of college in order to cover the war and make her mark before it all ends and ultimately grew into a respected photo-journalist covering the war as well as into a person who counts, even personifies, the human toll of the war. Her unique situation in country allows her to see the war from multiple perspectives, to sympathize with each side and to mourn casualties and devastation alike.

When Helen arrives in Vietnam, she is one of the few Western women in the country and in fact she remains an oddity like this for the duration of the war. She connects with a group of male journalists, having an affair with one of these jaded and doomed men. As his protege, she meets a local translator and goes on junkets with troops, honing her craft as she faces the realities of the war through the eyes of the local villagers as well as the young, scared American troops. Under Darrow's tutelage, she learns to be a brilliant photographer becoming addicted to the war, to the adrenaline-rush, to the danger, and to Vietnam itself. In the end, Helen is also addicted to Linh, a Vietnamese man who is a deserter, her interpreter, the man to whom her well-being was entrusted by Darrow and ultimately her lover and husband. Linh is incredibly conflicted, having been conscripted into an army and having suffered unimaginable losses because of the ongoing war. Together, this young, enthusiastic American woman and this emotionally battered Vietnamese man forge an unbending connection to each other and to the truth of the war they are living.

It is really the human connection that makes this novel so powerful and affecting. Soli invokes the reality of place and the horror of war without passing judgment but without white-washing anything either. Helen is a naive and appealing character at the beginning of the story and she is a strong and wonderful character, albeit one without any illusions, at the end. Linh is a multi-dimensional character with a real and realistic emotional reserve. The framing technique, whereby the story starts with the fall of Saigon and with the difficult and painful goodbye between Helen and Linh, only to go back in time and start at the beginning of the war, at the very nascence of their relationship, before love, is incredibly effective. Knowing the ending, being given the essence of the novel first, does not detract from its addictive sway over the reader at all, in fact it heightens the appreciation of the journey. Obsession, war, love, expedience, all are written into these pages with a meticulous eye to detail and poetry. Highly recommended for those in search of a gripping, well-written novel.

Thanks to the publisher for sending me a copy of this book for review.


  1. This sounds like a good one Kristen; I do have a copy so I appreciate your review.

  2. I loved this book, and I agree with you that the human connection packs a punch in this novel. We'll get your review up on WTTG soon.

  3. I really loved this book as well. Great review.

    We've got the review linked on the war blog review page and here: http://warthroughthegenerations.wordpress.com/2010/11/22/reviews-the-lotus-eaters-by-tatjana-soli/

  4. I'm reviewing this one for a blog tour next month and am really looking forward to it. I'm glad to hear you enjoyed it! I'm contemplating reading Matterhorn right after this one and gorging on Vietnam novels.

  5. I've got a copy of this one on mt tbr, glad you enjoyed it so much!


I have had to disable the anonymous comment option to cut down on the spam and I apologize to those of you for whom this makes commenting a chore. I hope you'll still opt to leave me your thoughts. I love to hear what you think, especially so I know I'm not just whistling into the wind here at my computer.

Popular Posts